A time clock can identify people in up to five ways, depending on the terminal: face, fingerprint, proximity card, magnetic-stripe or barcode badge, and keypad entry. Each looks fine in a brochure. They differ in three costs that only show up on a working floor: the queue at the change of shift, what gets touched and by whom, and what is left to argue about afterwards.
Maintained by the TriblockHR Compliance Team. Updated 2 October 2026. This page compares identification methods by capability; it names no terminal maker or model and states no queue-time figure.
Three costs, defined
Queue. At the change of shift, forty people want to clock out and forty want to clock in, all in the same ten minutes. A method that takes a moment longer per person, or fails and needs a second try, turns that window into a line at the door.
Hygiene. What does each person touch, and how many others touched it in the last hour? In a kitchen, a clinic or a food plant, that is not a minor question.
Disputes. What is left to argue about afterwards? A punch somebody denies making, a punch made for someone else, a missing punch blamed on the clock. The method decides how strong the record is when that conversation happens.
Take an invented hotel, Turtle Bay Resort, with a back-of-house entrance used by kitchen, housekeeping, engineering and security staff, and a shift change at 3pm that sends about eighty people past the clock.
Face
Facial recognition asks nothing of the person except to stand in front of the terminal. The source page describes identification as under a second on the larger terminals.
- Queue: strong. Nothing to find in a pocket, nothing to press. A housekeeper carrying linen can clock in without putting it down.
- Hygiene: strong. Nothing is touched.
- Disputes: strong. The person is identified by their face, so “someone else clocked in for me” is hard to sustain.
Where face struggles is placement and light. A terminal facing a bright doorway, or mounted at a height that suits nobody, slows everyone down. That is a site decision, and it is worth getting right before the first shift. What the terminal keeps to make face work is covered in why a biometric template should never leave the device.
Fingerprint
Fingerprint is familiar, and on a dry, clean hand it is quick and reliable.
- Queue: good with clean hands, poor with wet, floury, greasy or gloved ones. A line cook coming off a shift, or a mechanic from the engineering bay, may need two or three tries.
- Hygiene: weak in kitchens and food production. Everyone touches the same reader.
- Disputes: strong when it works. The difficulty is the person whose print reads poorly, who starts to find reasons not to clock.
At Turtle Bay, fingerprint suits the front-office staff who arrive with clean hands, and not the kitchen.
Card and badge
A proximity card, or a magnetic-stripe or barcode badge, is presented to the terminal.
- Queue: good, if people carry the card. Poor on the morning someone left it at home.
- Hygiene: good for proximity cards, which are held near the reader. A swiped badge touches the reader.
- Disputes: weak. A card identifies the card. The card on someone else’s lanyard, clocking in a friend who is running late, is the dispute card methods invite.
Cards earn their place where biometrics are unwelcome or impractical, and as a fallback for the employee who will not use a biometric method.
Keypad, and mixing methods
Keypad entry is a number typed on the terminal.
- Queue: slow at volume. Typing a code takes longer than a glance.
- Hygiene: weak. Everyone presses the same keys.
- Disputes: weakest. A code can be shared, written down or watched.
Keypad is the right fallback and the wrong everyday method. It covers the person whose face is not yet enrolled, the person whose card is lost, and the day a reader misbehaves.
One practical point applies to all five: whichever method is chosen for a door, the people who use that door should know what the fallback is before the first morning. A notice by the terminal saying “if face does not work, use your card or your code” saves a queue on day one.
A single site can mix methods. Turtle Bay might set face for most back-of-house staff, card for the two people who prefer not to use biometrics, and keypad as the fallback for all. Capabilities vary by terminal, so the mix depends on the hardware at each door; no single unit should be assumed to do all five.
The authentication method is recorded on each punch and is a reportable dimension: you can filter, group and sort by it, beside the device. A face, a fingerprint and a card stay distinguishable afterwards. That turns the method question from a guess into a number.
The number to watch is manual punches. Each account decides whether managers may add punches by hand. If they may, a rising count of hand-added punches at one door is the clearest sign that the method there is failing: people are not clocking, and supervisors are covering for it. A falling share of keypad punches after face enrolment is a sign the rollout is working. Enrolling a whole workforce is covered in enrolling a workforce that does not sit at a desk.
Whatever the method, the punch becomes a timesheet line, meets the overtime thresholds set per employment level, and reaches the pay run as hours.
Questions
Which identification methods can a terminal use?
Up to five, depending on the terminal: face, fingerprint, proximity card, magnetic-stripe or barcode badge, and keypad.
Which method is best for a kitchen?
Usually face: nothing is touched, and wet or floury hands do not matter.
Is the method recorded?
Yes. The method is recorded on each punch and can be filtered, grouped and sorted.
How do you tell a method is failing?
Watch hand-added punches, if managers are allowed to add them. A rising count at one door means people are not clocking there.
Choose the method that suits each door, and let the punch record which one was used.
- SOC 2 Type II attested
- AES-256 at rest
- 99.9% uptime
- Built in The Bahamas
